A comparison between the views on human nature of mencius and hsun tzu

If human beings are naturally good, where might evil originate. Propriety is manifested in respect 6A6 or deference 2A6 toward elders and legitimate authority figures, especially as manifested in ceremonies and etiquette. They become obsessed with this one part and mistake it for the entirety of the Way.

The function of the heart is to regulate the sense faculties and parts of the body, so that though one may have desires, the heart only acts on those desires when it is right to do so.

Government was based on a gradation of social relationships. In this respect, he could be considered anti-metaphysical, since he has no interest in how the world works or what it is. In the early 20th century, many Chinese intellectuals became part of the May 4th Movement, which called for China to rapidly Westernize and modernize.

As the pianist is still playing someone else's music, the sage does not make up new standards of conduct; he still follows the Way, but he makes it his own. Young age is important, for it is at this time that their perspectives drastically split. Confucius clearly saw it and to stop the emerging of any secondary society and to set up an example, Confucius determined to hold himself back from any original thinking along the way of a new secondary society.

Hsun Tzu and Mencius: How might Mencius perceive the nature of evil. Both Confucius and Plato refused to accept such a view: Though Xunzi was undoubtedly influenced by the principles of argument developed by the Mohists, he had no patience for the dialectical games and disputation for its own sake that were popular at the time.

If we think, we will get them the principles of things [or the appropriate responses to given situations]. While certain aspects of the Way, such as particular rituals, are certainly created by humanity, whether the Way as a whole is created or discovered remains a matter of scholarly debate.

This kind of division between knowledge of the human world and knowledge of Heaven may have been partially influenced by Zhuangzi, but while Zhuangzi considers knowing Heaven to be important, Xunzi does not. People are not naturally inclined to do evil.

Then all of a sudden, she is chattering continuously with her mother or other girls around three and four. Men have these Four Beginnings just as they have their four limbs.

He also claimed that everything else was a learned behavior based on social standards and societal demands. And this is why the second question is so strong: Just as one would not learn piano from someone who had just read a book on piano pedagogy but never touched an actual instrument, one should not study from someone who has only learned texts.

Zhuangzi never refers to Mencius by name, but several passages seem to clearly be directed at him.

Xunzi (Hsün Tzu, c. 310—c. 220 B.C.E.)

These points are expressed in an argument Mencius has with the Mohist Yi Zhi. They were created precisely because people do not act in accordance with them naturally. Therefore, man must first be transformed by the instructions of a teacher and guided by ritual principles, and only then will he be able to observe the dictates of courtesy and humility, obey the forms and rules of society, and achieve order.

This is the difference between the man-made secondary society and the natural primary society: If a doctrine does not lean toward Yang Zhu, then it leans toward Mozi. A Comparison of Confucius with Plato and Aristotle in Political Philosophy A Comparison of Socrates, Plato, Aristotle with Confucius, Mencius, and Hsun Tzu.

By far the most comparable three and sitting deep in our mind while Confucius thought that our human world was based on nothing but pure uncontaminated human nature. 2. Mencius as defender of Confucius against Mo Zi/ Mo Tzu and the Taoists/Daoists.

Mencius's emphasis on the innate human moral nature was a rebuttal against the writings of Mo Tzu and early Taoists who did not think human intentions/motives mattered.

As Mencius is known for the slogan "human nature is good," Xunzi is known for its opposite, “human nature is bad.” Mencius viewed self-cultivation as developing natural tendencies within us.

Xunzi believes that our natural tendencies lead to conflict and disorder, and what we need to do is radically reform them, not develop them. xunzi challenged mencius' positive concept of human nature as fundamentally good. xunzi themes.

reaffirm confucian values-learning, culture, human perfection mencius vs xunzi education.

Hsun Tzu and Mencius: Conflicting Perspectives of Society

mencius-education as natural development of inherent tendencies xunzi-education as effort to. Wendy Swartz The Nature of Evil Hsun Tzu's philosophy is built from the idea that human beings are by nature inherently evil, and the good they produce will only come through their conscious activity.

Opposing Views: Innate Good. Meng Tzu (or Mencius) was a Chinese philosopher, poet, novelist, and statesman. Today, he is still considered to be the second most important figure in Confucianism, with Confucius himself being the most important.

A comparison between the views on human nature of mencius and hsun tzu
Rated 0/5 based on 97 review
Opposing Views - Is Man Good or Evil?